fix(cilium): declare the agent metrics Service so cilium_* is scraped (REN-147)
ci/woodpecker/pr/ci-manifests-test Pipeline was successful
ci/woodpecker/pr/ci-scripts-test Pipeline was successful
ci/woodpecker/pr/pr-review Pipeline was successful

The cilium chart renders templates/cilium-agent/service.yaml only when
prometheus.enabled AND (prometheus.serviceMonitor.enabled OR
prometheus.metricsService). infrastructure/cilium/helmrelease.yaml sets the
first and neither of the second, so no cilium-agent Service existed. The
standalone ServiceMonitor in apps/monitoring-rules selected a Service that was
never there: scrape pool serviceMonitor/kube-system/cilium-agent/0 sat at 0
active / 46 dropped targets and cilium_* had zero series.

Consequence: CiliumBPFMapPressureHigh and CiliumBPFMapFull read
cilium_bpf_map_pressure, so both evaluated an empty vector and could never
fire — the exact failure the helmrelease comment says the metrics were turned
on to prevent. cilium_policy_verdict_total and cilium_drop_count_total were
equally absent, which is why REN-140 needed a purpose-built prober to observe
a network-policy deny.

Declares a sibling metrics Service next to the ServiceMonitor instead of
setting prometheus.metricsService in the HelmRelease. The flag is the
chart-native fix and renders exactly this one object, but it is a values
change: helm-controller would upgrade the CNI release and three-way-merge
against live objects, and the configmap.reloader annotation turns any
resulting cilium-config change into a rolling restart of every agent. A
Service applied by the apps Kustomization cannot do that.

Naming follows authentik-outpost-servicemonitors.yaml: distinct name plus
app.kubernetes.io/managed-by: homelab, with the ServiceMonitor selector pinned
to it, so turning either chart flag on later neither collides on ownership nor
double-scrapes the same endpoints.

The helmrelease.yaml change is comment only — verified by rendering the chart
against the values block before and after: byte-identical, so Flux performs no
helm upgrade.

Co-Authored-By: Paperclip <noreply@paperclip.ing>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
svc-atlas
2026-09-26 03:44:02 +00:00
co-authored by Paperclip Claude Opus 5
parent d3f20d6d16
commit 17c1dece48
3 changed files with 99 additions and 9 deletions
@@ -1,8 +1,75 @@
---
# The agent metrics Service, declared here because the chart does not render
# one under our values (REN-147).
#
# cilium's templates/cilium-agent/service.yaml is gated twice:
#
# {{- if and .Values.agent (not .Values.preflight.enabled) .Values.prometheus.enabled }}
# {{- if (or .Values.prometheus.serviceMonitor.enabled .Values.prometheus.metricsService) }}
#
# infrastructure/cilium/helmrelease.yaml sets `prometheus.enabled: true` and
# `prometheus.serviceMonitor.enabled: false`, and leaves `metricsService` at its
# default of false. First gate passes, second does not. The chart's fallback
# branch is envoy-only and needs envoy in the agent pod, but envoy runs as its
# own DaemonSet here — so no `cilium-agent` Service was rendered at all.
#
# The consequence was silent: agents exported metrics on :9962 all along, the
# ServiceMonitor below selected a Service that did not exist, and the scrape
# pool sat at 0 active / 46 dropped targets. `cilium_*` had zero series, so
# CiliumBPFMapPressureHigh and CiliumBPFMapFull in prometheusrule-cilium.yaml
# evaluated an empty vector forever and could never fire.
#
# Why a Service here and not `prometheus.metricsService: true` in the
# HelmRelease: that flag is the chart-native fix and its rendered diff is
# exactly this one object (it appears in no other template — not the
# ConfigMap, not the DaemonSet). But setting it changes the HelmRelease values,
# which makes helm-controller run `helm upgrade` on the CNI release, and that
# three-way-merges against live objects. PROPOSAL-cilium-single-owner.md
# records that `cilium-config` has carried a `kubectl-patch` field manager; if
# any of that drift is still live, the upgrade reconciles it, and the
# `configmap.reloader.stakater.com/reload: cilium-config` annotation on the
# HelmRelease then rolls every agent node by node. A Service applied by the
# apps Kustomization cannot do that. If the drift is ever proven gone, delete
# this object and set `prometheus.metricsService: true` instead.
#
# Name and selector follow authentik-outpost-servicemonitors.yaml: a distinct
# name plus `app.kubernetes.io/managed-by: homelab`, so flipping either chart
# flag later renders the chart's own `cilium-agent` Service without an
# ownership conflict and without double-scraping the same endpoints.
apiVersion: v1
kind: Service
metadata:
name: cilium-agent-metrics
namespace: kube-system
labels:
app.kubernetes.io/managed-by: homelab
app.kubernetes.io/name: cilium-agent
app.kubernetes.io/part-of: cilium
# Copied onto every series by the ServiceMonitor's targetLabels below.
# The dashboard the chart ships queries
# cilium_bpf_map_pressure{k8s_app="cilium"}, so this label is load-bearing.
k8s-app: cilium
spec:
type: ClusterIP
# Headless on purpose: agent metrics are per-node and every endpoint has to
# be scraped. A ClusterIP would hand Prometheus one random agent per scrape.
clusterIP: None
# Agent pods only. cilium-envoy carries k8s-app: cilium-envoy and exposes
# 9964, so it cannot match.
selector:
k8s-app: cilium
ports:
# Named and numbered exactly as the chart's own Service, so the
# ServiceMonitor below stays a field-for-field copy of the chart's.
- name: metrics
port: 9962
targetPort: prometheus
protocol: TCP
---
# Cilium's agent ServiceMonitor, declared here rather than by the chart.
#
# Reproduces what cilium 1.20.1 renders with prometheus.serviceMonitor.enabled,
# taken field for field off the live object so scraping is unchanged: same name,
# same namespace, same selector, same 10s interval and node relabeling.
# Reproduces what cilium renders with prometheus.serviceMonitor.enabled: same
# name, same namespace, same 10s interval and node relabeling.
#
# It lives here because the chart's template is gated on monitoring.coreos.com/v1
# existing at install time, and on an empty cluster it does not — those CRDs
@@ -22,13 +89,14 @@ metadata:
app.kubernetes.io/part-of: cilium
spec:
selector:
# Pinned to the Service above. Without managed-by this would also match a
# chart-rendered `cilium-agent` Service and scrape the same endpoints twice.
matchLabels:
app.kubernetes.io/managed-by: homelab
app.kubernetes.io/name: cilium-agent
namespaceSelector:
matchNames:
- kube-system
# The chart's Service keeps rendering (prometheus.enabled), so the target and
# its `metrics` port are there regardless of who declares the ServiceMonitor.
targetLabels:
- k8s-app
endpoints:
@@ -30,6 +30,9 @@ resources:
- prometheusrule-dns-resolution.yaml
- probes-dns.yaml
- alloy-servicemonitor.yaml
# Agent metrics. Ships the metrics Service as well as the ServiceMonitor:
# the chart renders neither under our values, so this scraped nothing and
# the two CiliumBPFMapPressure alerts could never fire. See the file.
- cilium-servicemonitor.yaml
- cnpg-podmonitors.yaml
- crowdsec-servicemonitor.yaml
@@ -72,10 +72,29 @@ spec:
# alertable beforehand.
#
# That reasoning is about the metrics, which this line provides. The
# ServiceMonitor is only the scrape wiring and is declared standalone in
# apps/monitoring-rules instead — the same treatment velero/helmrelease
# already gives its own, and for the same reason: the chart's template is
# gated on monitoring.coreos.com/v1 existing at install time.
# scrape wiring — both the ServiceMonitor and the metrics Service — is
# declared standalone in apps/monitoring-rules/cilium-servicemonitor.yaml
# instead. For the ServiceMonitor that is the same treatment
# velero/helmrelease already gives its own, and for the same reason: the
# chart's template is gated on monitoring.coreos.com/v1 existing at
# install time.
#
# The Service is there for a different reason, and it is the one that
# bit us (REN-147). templates/cilium-agent/service.yaml renders only when
# `prometheus.enabled` AND (`serviceMonitor.enabled` OR `metricsService`).
# With serviceMonitor.enabled false and metricsService at its default,
# no Service was rendered, so the standalone ServiceMonitor selected
# nothing and cilium_* had zero series for as long as this file has
# looked like this. Turning either flag on here is the chart-native fix
# and would render exactly that one object — but it is a values change,
# so helm-controller would upgrade the CNI release and three-way-merge
# against live objects, and the reloader annotation above turns any
# resulting cilium-config change into a rolling restart of every agent.
# Hence the Service is applied by the apps Kustomization, which cannot.
#
# If you ever do set `serviceMonitor.enabled` or `metricsService` here,
# delete the matching object from cilium-servicemonitor.yaml in the same
# change.
#
# Here it is worse than for velero. Cilium's chart does not skip the
# template, it aborts rendering — "Service Monitor requires